Montalbano’s Reluctant Investigation

The Shape of Water

Montalbano moves from routine response to an unofficial inquiry, following discrepancies even as powerful people demand closure.

increasing

Bearing strength in each event

decreasing

Called from a Dream Called from a Dream from "The Shape of Water". Called from a Dream The Call Fazio wakes Montalbano to report a possible death at the Pasture.

Called from a Dream from "The Shape of Water". Called from a Dream The Call Fazio wakes Montalbano to report a possible death at the Pasture.

Called from a Dream The Call Fazio wakes Montalbano to report a possible death at the Pasture. The inspector arrives expecting a gang killing, then learns the dead man is Luparello. First Judgment The body’s condition prompts suspicion, although the autopsy soon points to natural causes.

Forty-Eight Hours Forty-Eight Hours from "The Shape of Water". Forty-Eight Hours Institutional Pressure The judge, prefect, commissioner, clergy, and political figures all urge a rapid conclusion.

Forty-Eight Hours from "The Shape of Water". Forty-Eight Hours Institutional Pressure The judge, prefect, commissioner, clergy, and political figures all urge a rapid conclusion.

Forty-Eight Hours Institutional Pressure The judge, prefect, commissioner, clergy, and political figures all urge a rapid conclusion. Montalbano asks for two more days without claiming to possess proof. Private Instinct His delay rests on a mismatch between Luparello’s caution and the place of his death.

Following the Physical Clues Following the Physical Clues from "The Shape of Water". Following the Physical Clues Patient Work Montalbano tests the route to the Pasture, studies witness accounts, and searches the abandoned factory.

Following the Physical Clues from "The Shape of Water". Following the Physical Clues Patient Work Montalbano tests the route to the Pasture, studies witness accounts, and searches the abandoned factory.

Following the Physical Clues Patient Work Montalbano tests the route to the Pasture, studies witness accounts, and searches the abandoned factory. Small discrepancies outweigh official certainty. Changing Focus The inquiry shifts from how Luparello died to who arranged the scene.

The Widow’s Evidence The Widow’s Evidence from "The Shape of Water". The Widow’s Evidence A New Interpretation Mrs. Luparello points out that her husband’s underwear was reversed, suggesting he had been dressed hastily after…

The Widow’s Evidence from "The Shape of Water". The Widow’s Evidence A New Interpretation Mrs. Luparello points out that her husband’s underwear was reversed, suggesting he had been dressed hastily after…

The Widow’s Evidence A New Interpretation Mrs. Luparello points out that her husband’s underwear was reversed, suggesting he had been dressed hastily after being surprised naked. A Political Theory She sees an assault on his public image, not necessarily a murder, and gives Montalbano keys to his private cottage.

Closing Without Resolution Closing Without Resolution from "The Shape of Water". Closing Without Resolution The Limit of Proof Montalbano lays out his reconstruction but admits that evidence cannot prove it.

Closing Without Resolution from "The Shape of Water". Closing Without Resolution The Limit of Proof Montalbano lays out his reconstruction but admits that evidence cannot prove it.

Closing Without Resolution The Limit of Proof Montalbano lays out his reconstruction but admits that evidence cannot prove it. The commissioner recognizes its plausibility and its legal weakness. Choice Montalbano prepares to let the official inquiry close, carrying the unresolved truth privately.

Early Monday morning

The day after the autopsy

During the investigation’s middle days

The day before the funeral

After the account to the commissioner